Arcadian (review) – formidable creature and sound design save Brewer’s flawed post-apocalyptic thriller

13th June 2024

Arcadian is showing in cinemas nationwide from June 14.

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Benjamin Brewer’s post-apocalyptic mash-up of A Quiet Place, Alien and The Descent may not offer anything new in the crowded landscape of post-apocalyptic thrillers, but Arcadian does manage to keep its head above water with jump scares, tension, a cracking ensemble cast and fabulous creature design. Arcadian opens with Paul (Nicholas Cage) running through a dark, dystopian world of crumbling buildings, tannoy warnings and explosions. Paul has two infant sons, and his only concern is to protect them at any cost from the crumbling and dying world around them. We then jump forward fifteen years to a small rundown farmhouse on the edge of a forest, where Paul, Joseph (Jaeden Martell), and Thomas (Maxwell Jenkins) live lives dictated by the rising and setting sun. It is a world where only a small number of human survivors eke out a meagre existence on what food they can find or grow in a fight for survival. No one seems sure, or the adults stay silent, on what happened to their world over a decade before or where the strange creatures that hunt them at night came from. Some think these creatures were born from the pollution the human race churned out, while others believe that they were always there, deep under the surface of the Earth. They only know that as the sun sets, safety isn’t guaranteed as the creatures crawl from their underground homes to feed on human flesh.



Joseph has a scientific interest in the nocturnal creatures that desire his and his family’s blood. At the same time, Thomas wants to live free from the constraints of the rules their father applies, sneaking to the Rose farm across the forest whenever he can to see a girl named Charlotte (Sadie Soverall) who lives with an armed group of adults. There is clearly a history between the adults at the Rose farm and Cage’s Paul, which has strangely stopped them from teaming up. But the adults at the farm seem only too willing to embrace Jenkin’s Thomas. However, when Thomas has an accident sneaking back as the sun sets, Paul has no option but to rescue his son as the creatures come out to feed.

Anyone expecting a full-on Nicholas Cage-driven post-apocalyptic creature flick is bound to be slightly disappointed, as this isn’t Cage’s movie. Jenkins, Martell, and Soverall take centre stage in Mike Nilon’s atmospheric story of survival, love, and hunters turned prey. And it’s fair to say all three do a damn fine job; however, a frustrating lack of character development also plagues Brewer’s film and ultimately leaves us with far more questions than answers. Interesting story arcs are introduced only to be left hanging, from the reason the Rose Farm won’t accept Paul and Joseph but opens its arms to Thomas to the division created between two brothers when one finds love and the other is left alone. There are also questions about how much the adults really know and whether they have chosen to hide the truth from the few young people left. Due to impeccable sound design, formidable creature effects, perfectly timed jump scares and engaging performances, Arcadian just about rises above its narrative flaws, but that doesn’t mean you aren’t left feeling that Brewer and Nilon could have explored so much more in this dystopian thriller.


Previous Story

Brats (Tribeca Review) – Andrew McCarthy explores the power of words in defining public perception and private self-confidence

Next Story

My Sweet Land (Sheffield DocFest Review) – a powerful, urgent and intimate exploration of inter-generational trauma

Go toTop