A TEACHER "Episode 1” (Airs Tuesday, November 10) - - Pictured: (l-r) Kate Mara as Claire Walker, Nick Robinson as Eric Walker. CR: Chris Large/FX
//

A Teacher – Outstanding performances are let down by a confused narrative

Home Entertainment Quick Picks

2 mins read

A Teacher is streaming now on BBC iPlayer

Based on her 2013 movie of the same name, Hannah Fidell expands her original story of a teacher/pupil affair into a mini-series for FX, with mixed results. The TV version managing to expand the narrative of the film as promised. While equally attempting to focus on the affair’s outcomes for both the student (Nick Robinson) and teacher (Kate Mara).

Claire (Mara) has just joined the teaching team at a high school in Austin, where Eric (Robinson) is a senior. Here, Eric’s social circle of seniors immediately home in on the new young teacher. Their conversations a mix of male bravado, conquest and sexualised play that makes Eric feel uncomfortable. However, following a chance encounter in a local coffee shop, Claire agrees to mentor and support Eric; the boundaries between both student and teacher already tricky to define. And as time passes, the already loose professional boundaries fall away. Both Claire and Eric entering into a passionate, consensual but confusing affair.

Despite the effort taken to flesh out the movie’s narrative, A Teacher struggles to connect with its audience on a deeper level; despite its leads’ outstanding performances. The characters motivations often lacking both substance and time as events unfold in short 25-minute episodes. This flaw is all the more confusing given TV’s ability to build larger narrative arcs. However, some blame may lie within the choice of episodic structure and the lack of time it creates.

But, it is the last three episodes that are the most problematic. Each one attempting to explore themes of guilt, coercion and judgement while largely steering clear of any risky or insightful commentary. And this only creates a mixed and confusing statement on the affair at the heart of the show. One that feels strangely incomplete as the final scenes play out.


Read More Silk Road


LATEST POSTS

Foundation

Foundation – An extraordinary and lavish TV epic that is brave, bold and beautiful

Foundation is now showing on Apple TV. If you thought Dune was the only epic science fiction adaptation in town this Autumn, think again. Apple TV’s adaptation of Issac Asimov’s legendary Foundation is both beautiful, complex and utterly fascinating. To say, David S. Goyer, Josh Friedman, Skydance and Apple took a significant risk on Foundation

Long Day's Journey into Night

Long Day’s Journey into Night (1962)

Long Day’s Journey into Night is available to rent now on Apple TV. Films that take place in one location, with a limited number of actors, are in a way a true testament to the power of cinema. These films have a much harder time pulling in audiences due to their limited creative resources, relying

Everybody's Talking About Jamie

Everybody’s Talking About Jamie – Joyous, bright and proud

Everybody’s Talking About Jamie is showing now on Amazon Prime and in selected cinemas nationwide. The journey from stage to the big screen is never an easy one for any musical. Often the very things that make a stage musical successful with audiences fail to translate as they move to the screen. History is littered

Batman Year One

Batman: Year One – Warner Bros announces commemorative edition 4k Blu-ray

Warner Bros. Home Entertainment is celebrating the 10th anniversary of the DC Universe Movies release Batman: Year One with a fully-remastered version of the film and a newly-created bonus feature, Reinventing Gordon. The film arrives in a 4K Ultra HD Combo Pack (USA $33.99 SRP; Canada $39.99 SRP; UK TBA) and on Digital starting November

Loading…

Something went wrong. Please refresh the page and/or try again.

Previous Story

Robin’s Wish (Rent or Buy Now)

Next Story

The Last Blockbuster – Can the video rental business really survive?